I was fortunate to get NOS RS fenders for my 68 during the restoration. The originals are in good enough shape to fix, just the normal rust areas. What would be a fair price to ask for the RS fenders, inner fenders, and fender extensions?

I have a set of GM 67 RS fenders. They sound to be in the same condition as yours, with
the basic rust at the bottom near the door. I have been asking for $300 pair for mine, so far no takers for a month. If my car didnt need a floor and rockers, making it IMO more a non gm original car, I would keep and use them. I didnt think that was a bad price when good ones are going for $1,500!! I would even trade for a good pair of repo. standard fenders or a pair of gm fenders in same condition.

bought my 68 rs fenders (almost rust-free, just a small spot on the driver side lower part by door, but needed some other work as well) for $125. I would say that the fenders are worth about 150, the inners for another 50-100, and the fender extensions for another 25-50 depending on who you have wanting them. I would say overall they are worth 300 but would def. ask more. I am stating my prices in terms of what I would want to buy them for if I needed them, not the seller's view of what I want for them.

Sleeper, did you pay $125 for the pair or each? Your a good finder, please find me a set of 67 std.s for $125/pair, or even each if needing only minor work.

125 for the pair - needed body line work from the tip back to the wheel opening. just a ton of stupid small dents, but I have original GM fenders which is what I was going for.

swap meets. just got to be there with cash. Just a side note, 68 fenders are the same as 67 fenders with the exception of the side marker light and emblem locations. I bought the 68 RS fenders for my 67 that I am converting to an RS.