Re: Cool Site, Hello! & Please Help!
With the police report in hand the DMV or police should be able/willing to check the VIN nationally. IF it was not re-VIN'd or chopped up and it was re-registered under that VIN, you will find the car.
If you do find the current "owner's" address however, be careful in how you go about contacting him. It would be a major shock to find out his pride and joy is not his--his first instinct will probably not be to hand you the car keys and the car.
I'd physically locate and photograph the location and the car, then contact the local police department, explain the situation and have them accompany you to the vehicle. The current "owner" may even be the person who "borrowed" it from you but it is probably just some guy who bought it from the thief.
That all said, if the insurance company paid you for the loss, I believe they now own the car. You might want check that out.
Keep us posted on your progress. Hopefully there are no TC'ers sitting at home crying on their keyboard because they "own" #124378N419121.
1968 RS/SS Lemans Blue