Yes he should...as a Bear.

 

:yes:

 

The short answer..NO!

 

I think he needs to go off into the sunset. He has played the I'm retired game to many times. Either retire or don't.

 

I agree Royce. It seems the big names want to retire two and three times!! Make up your mind people!!
On top of that I want to see Rodgers out there as he is from Chico, CA.

Doug

 

Yes but to a team who is really in need of qb and veteran leadership. You figure he has already won his superbowl and many other awards. Frankly speaking though to me winning one championship anymore isnt even the standard compared to others who have won more.

 

I am from Green Bay and the public is split on wanting him back. I think if he wants back he needs to come for two years and trade Rodgers.

 

Its still America right? Let him do what he wants. He runs the risk of not going out on top though..its his choice.

 

Yes, it is America and he has the right to do as he wishes, I also have the right to voice my opinion about it. He was/is a great QB I was rooting for him last year. With that said it is not fair to the team, his teamates, or the fans to play this retirement game every year. It won't effect my life either way. The question was asked and I gave my opinion.

 

I heard Brett's moving to Miami now that he's retired. He wants to get as far away from professional football as possible.

 

Yes, Jerry, Brett should come back. I'm incredibly excited about it, IF it happens.

 

He should have never retired in the first place. I picked NE over GB a year ago this month for the Super Bowl and everyone thought I was crazy. I liked what I saw from the Packers the last 4 games of 2006 and I figured they would be the suprise team of 2007. I also picked Favre in the 2nd to last round right before I drafted my kicker in one Fantasy Football league I play in. In the otehr one I also took him near the last rounds. The guy was money last year. AND I AM A BEARS FAN!!

In short, I think Favre made a mistake to retire. His team was one play from the Super Bowl last year. I think he now knows that. He may have 1 year left in him or possibly 2 years. But it may be too late. The Packers appear to have moved on without him and the off-seasons drama that he caused the past 3 and now 4 seasons. Send him to Chicago, we'll take 'em!

 

If he comes back, he needs to play for a warmer climate team. The cold weather during last years NFC Championship game made him look like a quitter. He's been a great pro for years, but in that particular game, Eli Manning showed alot more heart. JMO. Mike. :beers::beers:

 

:noway::yes:. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it .

 

Heck no.

Packer fans just can't seem to move on; still talk about the "Lombardi days" which ended almost 40 years ago. Remember, he came out of retirement in '69 to lead the Redskins to a ho-hum 7-5-2 record.

Go look at the last play of the season - Ryan Grant wide freakin' open in the middle of the field, #4 just has to force it to one of his well-covered buds, along the sideline no less. Easy pick; game, season over.

Move on - Aaron Rodgers is the guy. If push comes to shove I will bet the Packers will release Favre. No fool like an old fool.

 

Damn, no one got my Miami joke lol

 

Yes, I got the Miami joke and was going to respond and say it was very funny. I have couple friends that are Dophin fans.

 

Brett should not come back. He is admired, respected, even worshipped by hundreds of thousands of us, but he has had his moment(s) in the sun. It's time for a new Green Bay dominance. Besides, i'm also sick of the drama.
GO PACK GO!!!

 

who is Brett Favre ?
im into cars not game show host.

 

Brett is acting like a boxer....retire, unretire, retire, unretire.... :yes: If he wants to come back, fine....just with another team....The team doesn't need the drama...

 

Bring him back. I would like to see another season with him and his cannon. :thumbsup:

 

I've grown tired of all the drama myself, but If the man can still play, I'd say yes come back, but only to the Packers.

I agree his last game was an embarrassment, so I guess we'll see.

 

Who is this Brett Favre guy? I didn't no that Wisconsin even had a professional football team!

GO VIKINGS!!!!!

 

Ha ha ha; go vi-queens!

 

Guess they are no better quaterbacks out there? Slim pickens?

MBHD

 

yea as a n.o. saint

 

Now he wants the Packers to release him so he can pursue playing for another team . . .

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080711/ap_on_sp_fo_ne/fbn_packers_favre

 

I see that and quite frankly i really dont get it. The guy is a legend in G.B. and thats where he should retire from. To go play mediocre football with another team for a year or two and retire in obscurity makes no sense to me.

 

I think that Farve has an agreement with the local medias to keep the drama going ,it seems the people here thrive on it. Farve is a great player.I do not think this is fair to Rodgers. Rodgers can play,but has proven he is injury prone,if not for that,this would be a dead issue.

 

The Packers have stated he can return as a backup - he will not be traded or released.

His continual inablity to make a decision and stick to it has polarized the team and the fans. Rodgers is in a no-win stuation. What a dope...