Team Camaro Tech banner

Are all door shells created equally???

1 reading
14K views 20 replies 15 participants last post by  jay'srs/ss  
#1 ·
Looking for some advice from the voice(s) of experience. Are there more than one manufacturer of the repop door shells? Do the 69 door shells fit well?? Thanks in advance everyone!!
 
#4 ·
I would do a little research. I got both my doors from cars incorporated. One fit excellent, the second one came in a goodmark box and fits poorly compared to the not goodmark door. the issue I do not like is the gap on the bottom. one is quite large, but it could be the rear quarter, I repaced them also. basically all reproduction parts are time consuming to fit properly but with no time spared they can fit very well. I think lots of the parts have to do with timing and luck. I can picture them being pressed out and quality checked. Sometimes you get the good enough product and sometimes the best. good luck.
 
#8 ·
I believe Golden Legion is the mfr. In looking at 69 vert quarters, everyone (Cars Inc, Goodmark, NPD, etc) sells OER (Classic ) which is made by Golden Legion.
 
#10 ·
Dont use the doors for a 67. You nned to major fabricating, grinding to get the wing windows in. I have been through it. The one door needs metal added to fix the fender/door gap. The other was ok. Its not a walk in the park but they work..
 
#14 ·
I have a question-- Why do people buy crap?

Or maybe a better question-- How does a company get away with manufacturing parts that are not fit for use, and they still find buyers?

I just replace metal, and use pieces from other panels that are bad in other places. With the time involved with fitting overseas panels, and panels out of bad molds (new U.S.), you're better off cutting and welding.
 
#15 ·
Just go and find some solid doors that need the skins replaced. I just ordered a new set of Goodmark door skins and they came with the upper support bracket and fit really nicely. Lined up well to my GM fenders.
 
#16 ·
Best advice right there. I used a few shells on customers cars and they are a project to make them fit right. I was able to buy a rust free but dented to hell 68 door for $40 (placed an add in the classifieds here) and you can ship a door shell UPS if its boxed right. Add a repro skin and it should fit like a glove.
Problem with the repro shells is there is no car to fit the skin to. If the skin is off a 1/4 inch either way on the shell your screwed.When you put the skin on yourself you can hang the shell on the car,lay your skin on and position it perfectly.Mark it,take it all off,install the skin and it should fit your car perfectly.
 
#19 ·
Only concern was that the passenger side did not have the holes pre-drilled for a mirror -- but that's not a big deal.

Passenger mirror was a dealer option wasn't it? I know my car came with the drivers remote mirror only so I was glad there were no holes on the passenger side.
 
#20 ·
My buddy used the Goodmark stuff on his 69 and the door shells fit OK. The drivers fender needed a bracket cut off and shortened and rewelded to make it fit but after that everything lined up OK. For perfect showcar gaps more work would be needed but so would a GM fender or doorshell. I have Golden Legion quarters, doorshells and fenders I am putting on my 69 and they look good so far. Plenty of work ahead to fit them.