... I have read about a few different ways of doing this. ...
- split the bushing to remove... Damage the housing?
- using a puller tool... What is this?
- using the new bushing to push out the old one... Damage the new bushing?
- using a socket and a press. I do have access to a press at work... What size socket?
What is the best way to remove the old bushing and replace it with the new one?
While I truthfully can't remember exactly how a Muncie tail bushing is seated (

CRS has set in ...) I have done similar bushings in all of the 'bolded' ways above.
If you have access to the rear of the bushing, I will most often try to use the correct driver (or a socket) to drive/press it out.
If I can access it easily from the rear and there are clearance slots or a lip on the bushing I will use one of my 'inside' puller to pull it out that way.
My process of last resort is usually to try to split the bushing with a chisel (or a carefully crafted sharpened old screwdiver blade

) and remove it that way - this almost always leads to other things in my case ...
I would almost never use a 'new' bushing to drive out the old :noway:
Sure way to buldge the end of the new one and cause a tight fit or drag that will quickly ruin the new one in use
I just rebuilt a "Berkeley" Jet Drive a few months ago and had to use a combination of these peocedures to get all the bushings and bearings out of it. Some were just to dang deep in their housings for me to really reach, so a couple of long extensions on a socket allowed me to get them out and replaced.
I tend to work my way around these issues, as I hate to take stuff to a shop if I can do it - usually ...
If you are worried about damaging the housing, I would always defer the work to a qualified machinist or mechanic - maybe a local tranny shop has someone with a good set of drivers that could do it for you for reasonable price.
Hope this helps
btw - check with your local Harbor Freight Tool place, they have some cheap sets of drivers that could probably get most of the stuff out and replaced.
While I sure wouldn't call most of their stuff 'production' tool quality - they are good enough for these little 'onesy-twosy' type of jobs.