I don't know why I stopped getting notifications about posts but I came back to give more info. Sorry about the long post but wanted to give everyone that might be in the same boat as much detail as I can.
A buddy of mine has some 18x9/4.75 backspace with 275/40/18 and his fronts are 18x8/4.25 backspace on a '70 Chevelle. I took my Camaro over to his house try them on last weekend. First off the 18x9 with the 275 will by no means fit my car. Again, remember my car is lowered 2" in the rear. Those 275 on the 18x9 were about 1" on the outside of my rear fender well. The only way to get those will work would be to jack it up in the rear with some air shocks and that ain't happening!!
I then tried his 18x8/4.25 BS fronts on my rear and I believe they had 235/45/18 (I'm drawing a blank on the tire size but I'll confirm it and come back to edit). Those worked pretty well for my rear. I liked the look of the 18" on the rear and would choose that if it works out but I will say it wasn't a super dramatic difference over my 17" wheels. So, I'm good with the 18" on the rear and it will clear with maybe a slight ding in the rear section of the exhaust pipe just for good measure.
I also put his other 18x8 on my front and set the car on the ground. The tire went up into the fender well but that was pretty much it. There was about a 1/4" clearance if I was lucky. No way that isn't going to rub in a turn. On top of that it just looked off to me. The 18" was too big for the front IMO. I just didn't like the looks of it at all. At first my buddy thought the 18" up front looked fine but after about 10 minutes of looking at it, he agreed, the 18" up front was a no go with his setup. Maybe with an 18x7 up front and a lower profile tire but not the way this one looked. Besides, the US Mag I'm looking at, they only come in 18x9.5 or 18x8. I contacted US Mag and to get a 18x7 I would have to get a custom two piece wheel made and the price of one of their two piece wheels was the same cost of the whole set of pre-fabbed wheels....again, not something in my budget.
I actually have a picture of a '69 with the US Mags in an 17" and 18" staggered setup and it honestly looks it would possibly be workable. However, my personal preference is to not do staggered set ups. I think at first I might be okay with the two different sizes but eventually wouldn't want it. That's just my opinion on running staggered wheels. I know there are plenty of people out there who are good with staggered wheels but I'm just not one of them.
That being said, it looks like I'm going to go with the 17x7/4.0 backspace up front and 17x8/4.5 backspace out back.
So, now it's on to the tires. I'm currently running 17x7 with 205/50/17 and 17x8 with 245/45/17 for about 15 years now. My car is pretty damn low and I've have zero rubbing issues ever with this combo. That being said, I do think the rear 245 is borderline being too skinny out back. I would love to do a 275 but that's just not going to be in the cards with my car being lowered. I think the biggest I could get and not rub would be a 255/45/17 but that's only .4" wider over my current 245/45. Still, I'll take any width I can get if it doesn't rub. However, looking around there seems to be 10x as many brands that have a 245 than 255. I've run Sumitomo tires for the last 15 years with good luck. I know they are cheap and probably not the best performing tire but I don't drag race, auto-X, or road race my car. I only drive it around town to car shows and so forth and I estimate I put about 1,000 miles a year average on my car so my tires usually need to be replaced due to age rather than being worn out. The Sumitomo's are super cheap on price, I was quoted all 4 tires mounted and balanced out the door for $400 even.
Looks like when it's all said and done, I'm going to be going back to my same set up of 17x7 with the 205 up front and 17x8 with 245 on the rear. Total wheel and tire package price is going to be $1,200 turn key for everything including installation and taxes.
I'm still going to keep my current Boyds wheels in case I ever want to go back. I'll try to post some pictures when everything is all done within the next couple weeks or so.